Media Releases

MEDIA RELEASE: Absence Of Men From Childcare 'a National Disgrace'

Absence of men from childcare 'a national disgrace' Media Release 24 September, 8.19pm New Zealand's largest representative body of licensed early childhood centres has called for a partnership between Government and childcare organizations to encourage more men into childcare. The call follows tonight's (24 September) Sunday Programme (on ONE) which revealed men were more than two per cent of those working in early childhood care ('teacher-staffed, government-funded early childhood services') in 1992, but less than one per cent today – and falling. The Early Childhood Council said the absence of men from early childhood teaching was 'a national disgrace'. Chief Executive Sue Thorne said New Zealand compared 'very badly' to other developed countries and the need for action was 'urgent'. 'With few men in our primary schools and fewer in childcare centres we have created a society in which we have quarantined our children from our men. 'This is a project of destructive social change with very negative consequences for children.' She said 'the paedophile hysteria' of the 1990s had caused good men to vacate roles caring for children. Many men don't feel welcome in childcare, she said. 'They feel they will be treated as suspect until proven innocent. And we know, as a matter of record, that some parents will not enroll children in a centre if men are present. 'We have created a culture in which it can be dangerous to reputation and future for a childcare male to cuddle a distressed child, to change a nappy or express affection. This anti-male bias, however, does not change the fact that children need to experience men as nurturing.' The presence of men in childcare was important for the many children being brought up with absent fathers, she said. And it was especially important if such children came from 'at-risk' environments in which they had experienced men as unreliable or abusive. The potential benefits of such children spending time with strong, gentle men were incalculable, Mrs Thorne said. She said there was 'great irony' in the fact that 'the current situation is perpetuated by those who would otherwise proclaim most loudly an opposition to sexism'. 'Why is it that the same people who speak with passion about the absence of women from the boardroom are silent about the absence of men from the classroom? 'Why is it that there would be an outcry were women excluded from the promotion of careers in the army or law or medicine, but there is silence when men are excluded in advertising for childcare?' Mrs Thorne called for a partnership between the Government, the teacher unions, the education institutions and child care associations to get more men onto the childcare frontline. 'There was a time, only a few years ago, when few doctors, lawyers or journalists were women, but we changed that' she said. 'They've achieved substantial increases in male participation in childcare overseas and I see no reason why the same could not be achieved in New Zealand.' Men were needed to help resolve severe labour shortages in the sector, Mrs Thorne said. 'The system needs them. The children need them. It's time things changed.' The Early Childhood Council, headed by Mrs Thorne, has 940 member centres (both community-owned and commercially owned) which employ more than 6000 staff and care for more than 50,000 children. Click the link below to download a copy of the policy paper Men at Work. Sexism in Early Childhood Education. The paper features articles written by four men on their experiences of being involved in early childhood work. The writers point to difficulties in being men in a predominantly female job. Men at Work. Sexism in Early Childhood Education The ECC's media release has attracted a lot of attention in the print and radio media this week. Have a look at the links below to read some of the articles. Dominion Post - Males victims of childcare 'sexism' TVNZ - Fears force men from childcare Newstalk ZB - Children being "quarantined" from men The Press - Men needed for childcare NZ Herald - Teachers can touch children, says union Press Release - The elephant in the schoolroom NZ Herald - Readers Views The Southland Times -Editorial Sleaze and Safety

25/09/06 - Anthony Keesing